Earlier this summer, in Trustees of the Mrs PL Travers Will Trust v HMRC [2013] UKFTT 436 (TC), 14 August 2013, a First-tier Tribunal in the UK found that whether copyright royalties payable to trustees were taxable as
capital or income depended on an analysis of copyright ownership in the light
of trust law principles. The Tribunal also considered what constituted accumulation
of income, where royalties were being exploited.
Curiously, in reaching its decision the tribunal
judges had to refer to a line of Scottish cases relating to
mineral rights. This reflects the fact that there are not many cases on the tax and
trust treatment of copyright. This decision is therefore likely to be a useful
reference point for trustees who are holding copyright and for the executors of literary
estates as well as their advisers.
Cultural note: the P. L. Travers in this case is not as well known as her famous literary creation, this being none other than Mary Poppins.
"Where money issues meet IP rights". This weblog looks at financial issues for intellectual property rights: securitisation and collateral, IP valuation for acquisition and balance sheet purposes, tax and R&D breaks, film and product finance, calculating quantum of damages--anything that happens where IP meets money.
Thursday, 31 October 2013
Wednesday, 30 October 2013
More tools: but are they right for the job?
"Businesses to get greater Intellectual Property support" is the title of today's media release from the UK government's Department for Business, Innovation and Skills. According to its text:
"The potential for businesses to succeed and grow received a big boost today with the launch of new support tools to help small firms identify, protect and grow their intellectual property (IP) assets. The Intellectual Property Office launched ‘IP for Business’ - a suite of five business tools which make sure firms can tap into up-to-date guidance to help manage their IP. It will also help firms get more relevant advice from their accountants and other business advisers.
The tools respond to the challenge of making sure businesses can generate value from ideas against a backdrop of poor understanding of IP rights and how they can exploit them. At the centre of the toolkit is IP Equip - a new, free interactive online training tool that helps businesses and their advisors to identify assets which may be protected by IP rights and think through the strategy for protecting them. ...
Roger Burt, President of the Chartered Institute of Patent Attorneys, said:
“Small businesses and their advisors, if they understand it at all, generally see IP as a low priority. To engage their interest, you have to talk to them about its business benefits, not about the intricacies of intellectual property, particularly patent law. This new material does just that. It is a valuable addition to the tools already available.”President of the Institute of Trade Mark Attorneys Catherine Wolfe sees the new package as having a clear advantage over some of the existing materials:
“By focusing on the potential commercial value of IP assets these new tools make it clear to business people and their advisers that it pays to get expert help at an early stage. Having an effective IP strategy can be crucially important to business.”Other products being launched today include
- IP Equip app which is available to download free from the Apple store iTunes and Android App store. This will give access to IP information on the go.
- IP Basics which is a range of new guides for business owners, explaining how to maximise the potential of IP.
- IP Health Check which allows business owners to assess their own business for free with a tailored report to identify and value their IP.
While no-one can accuse the IPO of not trying, it would be good to know how effective these tools are: how far have they been test-driven and how widely applicable are they? Readers' experiences and evaluations would be particular welcome -- especially if they influence a decision whether to seek, or to advance, investment funding.
- IP Master Class which is a popular accredited course which enables advisors to advance their knowledge".
Tuesday, 29 October 2013
Coming soon: "From IP to NP"
On 10 and 11 November 2013 this blogger will be attending a conference, "From IP to NP", organised by the AIPPI's Israel chapter. The "NP" in this context stands for "net profit" and there is a strong international panel of speakers and contributors. The venue is the Dan Panorama Convention Center, Tel Aviv. David Kappos, Marshall Phelps and judges Randall R. Rader and Klaus Grabinski are among the participants.
Details of this conference, which will be concentrating on the business and commercial dimensions to IP exploitation, are available here.
I'd like to meet any readers of this blog who are attending the event: if you'll be there, do let me know by emailing me here.
Details of this conference, which will be concentrating on the business and commercial dimensions to IP exploitation, are available here.
I'd like to meet any readers of this blog who are attending the event: if you'll be there, do let me know by emailing me here.
Friday, 25 October 2013
When Successful Innovation and IP Go in a Different Direction from Increased Domestic Employment
Ever since the onset of the Great Recession, the primary concern of most governments has been to accelerate domestic growth in a way that will increase employment. For example, there is no more anticipated economic data point than the US unemployment rate, published on the first Friday of each month. For the general public, the success or failure of many governments is the extent to which they can generate jobs in a sustained and substantial way. The primacy of economic growth, and its by-product —increased employment — threaten to place public discussion about IP in an awkward position. The reason is that there may no clear connection between enhanced innovation and IP activity and improved employment data. Instead, the benefits of cutting-edge IP may well be redounding primarily to the benefit of the few who are able to capitalize on the commercial success of their innovations, with little or no benefit to the overall employment situation. To the extent that this is true, arguments in favour of public support of IP rest on uncertain policy grounds.
Take a country like Israel, which is seen as an example of the use of effective public moneys for innovative research and development. A primary vehicle for this funding is the so-called Office of the Chief Scientist (known as the OCS), which extends financial support for innovative activity by recipient companies, here. The problem is that OCS funding requires that the intangible “Knowledge” for which read IP, very broadly defined) that is generated from such funding may not be transferred out of the country until the grants have been repaid to the OCS from commercialization of the Knowledge, unless a waiver can be obtained. Underlying this prohibition is the view that OCS funding is, at the end of the day, first and foremost intended to enhance local employment, whereby the commercial success of the company, except to the extent that it contributes to local employment, is a secondary consideration. How strongly this underlying policy is viewed can be seen from the fact that, under the strict letter of the Encouragement of Industrial Research and Development Law, the transfer of Knowledge in an unauthorized fashion might theoretically attract criminal penalties (although this blogger is not aware of any instance in which the criminal sanction has actually been brought to bear).
Pushing against this clear nexus between the expenditure of public moneys, the creation of valuable IP/Knowledge, and increased domestic employment, as exemplified by OCS funding, is the exit ethos of the Israel start-up community. While it has become a bit hackneyed, the description of the country as “Start-Up Nation”, here, does capture the esteem in which is held a successful hi-tech exit (meaning that the company has been sold to a foreign purchaser or, less likely these days, has successfully floated its shares on a reputable stock exchange), replete with underlying IP and related innovative technology. However, from the point of view of government employment policy, a successful exit typically has, at best, only a modest effect on overall domestic employment. Even assuming that the company maintains an R&D facility in the country after the exit, the primary benefit of a successful exit are the millions, sometimes hundreds of millions of dollars, that go to the investors and founders. Thus, even if the likes of a Google maintains a local R&D facility as a result of the exit, the employment benefits redound to a select few, with the overall national employment situation being largely unaffected.
Israel is brought as an example because its circumstances so vividly underscore the proposition that the development of IP tends to go to the benefit of capital (read investors and founders) rather than labour. But it is hardly alone. Singapore is engaged in an impressive and aggressive push, supported by public funding, to strengthen the position of that island nation as a Global IP hub in Asia, here. As this blogger understands the initiative, underlying it is a concern for the overall employment position in the country. The experience in Israel should be a cautionary tale for Singapore.
Don’t get this blogger wrong: he is all in favour of IP, innovation and successful commercial exits based on them. To the extent that government funds can assist these developments, it is to be encouraged. However, there is palpable and increasing risk here. In an age where public budgets are increasingly scrutinized, a budget line for the support of innovation and R&D, where the benefit fails to redound to the public in the form of increased employment, carries with it a double risk. First, the decoupling of successful innovation and R&D from improved domestic employment threatens to decrease the amount of continued public funding of such activities. Even more ominously, this decoupling may threaten public support for robust IP protection, thereby throwing out the IP baby with the public funding bathwater in a way that this blogger would prefer not to contemplate.
Take a country like Israel, which is seen as an example of the use of effective public moneys for innovative research and development. A primary vehicle for this funding is the so-called Office of the Chief Scientist (known as the OCS), which extends financial support for innovative activity by recipient companies, here. The problem is that OCS funding requires that the intangible “Knowledge” for which read IP, very broadly defined) that is generated from such funding may not be transferred out of the country until the grants have been repaid to the OCS from commercialization of the Knowledge, unless a waiver can be obtained. Underlying this prohibition is the view that OCS funding is, at the end of the day, first and foremost intended to enhance local employment, whereby the commercial success of the company, except to the extent that it contributes to local employment, is a secondary consideration. How strongly this underlying policy is viewed can be seen from the fact that, under the strict letter of the Encouragement of Industrial Research and Development Law, the transfer of Knowledge in an unauthorized fashion might theoretically attract criminal penalties (although this blogger is not aware of any instance in which the criminal sanction has actually been brought to bear).
Pushing against this clear nexus between the expenditure of public moneys, the creation of valuable IP/Knowledge, and increased domestic employment, as exemplified by OCS funding, is the exit ethos of the Israel start-up community. While it has become a bit hackneyed, the description of the country as “Start-Up Nation”, here, does capture the esteem in which is held a successful hi-tech exit (meaning that the company has been sold to a foreign purchaser or, less likely these days, has successfully floated its shares on a reputable stock exchange), replete with underlying IP and related innovative technology. However, from the point of view of government employment policy, a successful exit typically has, at best, only a modest effect on overall domestic employment. Even assuming that the company maintains an R&D facility in the country after the exit, the primary benefit of a successful exit are the millions, sometimes hundreds of millions of dollars, that go to the investors and founders. Thus, even if the likes of a Google maintains a local R&D facility as a result of the exit, the employment benefits redound to a select few, with the overall national employment situation being largely unaffected.
Israel is brought as an example because its circumstances so vividly underscore the proposition that the development of IP tends to go to the benefit of capital (read investors and founders) rather than labour. But it is hardly alone. Singapore is engaged in an impressive and aggressive push, supported by public funding, to strengthen the position of that island nation as a Global IP hub in Asia, here. As this blogger understands the initiative, underlying it is a concern for the overall employment position in the country. The experience in Israel should be a cautionary tale for Singapore.
Don’t get this blogger wrong: he is all in favour of IP, innovation and successful commercial exits based on them. To the extent that government funds can assist these developments, it is to be encouraged. However, there is palpable and increasing risk here. In an age where public budgets are increasingly scrutinized, a budget line for the support of innovation and R&D, where the benefit fails to redound to the public in the form of increased employment, carries with it a double risk. First, the decoupling of successful innovation and R&D from improved domestic employment threatens to decrease the amount of continued public funding of such activities. Even more ominously, this decoupling may threaten public support for robust IP protection, thereby throwing out the IP baby with the public funding bathwater in a way that this blogger would prefer not to contemplate.
Monday, 21 October 2013
Heresy Implemented? Overreaching Claims by Trademark Attorneys and the Reaction by Courts and Administrative Bodies.
Numerous commentators (including myself) have pointed to
examples of how trademark practitioners may be essentially over-enforcing their
marks—sometimes perhaps justifying the label of “trademark bullies” for their
clients, see this blog
post. Recently, on Professor Oppedahl’s
popular trademark listserv,
a number of trademark attorneys noted how trademark attorneys at the United
States Patent and Trademark Office are issuing more office action refusals
based on “failure to function as a mark” (perhaps based on the fact that the
purported mark is failing to operate as a mark in connection with the submitted
specimen of use). Notably, in the
discussion, John
Welch, the blogger at the excellent TTAB blog, references a recent
article he authored that states that the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board
and courts have recently increased “discussions of utilitarian functionality,
aesthetic functionality, failure to function as a mark, inherent
distinctiveness, acquired distinctiveness, and non-reputation based competitive
advantage.” According to Mr. Welch, the
cause of such discussions may be aggressive lawyering by trademark
lawyers—perhaps meaning that trademark attorneys are broadly claiming trademark
protection and thus perhaps over-claiming by “pushing the envelope," and
the Trademark Office and courts are responding to that practice. I think Mr. Welch’s theory has merit. It would seem that attorneys representing
accused infringers against attorneys who may assert over-reaching trademark
claims would raise those arguments to protect their clients’ interests. Further, the more reported cases that address
those issues, the more likely it may be that trademark attorneys at the
Trademark Office may raise them in response to what they perceive as
over-reaching.
I do wonder whether the Trademark Office is influenced by
(and if not, should be influenced by) empirical evidence concerning how
consumers actually perceive marks instead of completely relying on the judicial
interpretation of consumer psychology (read the U.S. Supreme Court’s Qualitex and Wal-Mart decisions) that has pervaded U.S. trademark law, for
example with the Spectrum of Distinctiveness inquiry. (Of course, we do use surveys to test
consumer reaction to a mark). Could that
be part of the reason that the Trademark Office is increasing its discussions
of “aesthetic functionality, failure to function as a mark, inherent
distinctiveness, acquired distinctiveness, and non-reputation based competitive
advantage?” Could it be that the
Trademark Office is utilizing the doctrinal tools that it has to correct for
problems with our traditional tests for trademark protection, including the
Spectrum of Distinctiveness? (probably
not, but maybe it should be) Ordinarily,
a threshold issue for a court is whether the purported trademark owner has a
mark that is functioning as a trademark—the question is whether the mark
is distinctive. In a 2009 article in the
Arizona State Law Journal, Thomas R. Lee, Eric D. DeRosia, and Glen L.
Christensen, address the merits of the Spectrum of Distinctiveness, in An
Empirical and Consumer Psychology Analysis of Trademark Distinctiveness.
The authors state that:
The evaluation of consumer perception is hardly a
matter of judicial competence. Instead, like many of the key issues in
trademark law, questions of distinctiveness are matters that can and should be
informed by the theoretical and empirical tools employed by those who undertake
a careful, scholarly study of such issues. . . . Questions
of distinctiveness, in particular, lend themselves to rigorous theoretical
analysis using tools developed in the scholarly study of consumer psychology.
Such questions are not merely theoretical; they lend themselves to empirical
study using accepted methods of quantitative measurement.
That is the enterprise of this article. After first setting forth some
additional background on the law's classification of word marks (in Part II),
we consider the justifications offered in the scholarly literature for the law
in this area (in Part III). Finding those justifications analytically
unsatisfying and largely question-begging, we marshal theoretical tools from
the field of consumer psychology (in Part IV) that provide important insights
into the viability of the law's word mark taxonomy. Using these tools, we show
that the law's longstanding assumptions about consumer perception of word marks
are highly questionable. Specifically, we employ consumer psychology models of
the way consumers perceive visual information
to hypothesize that when identifying a product's source, consumers will rely
primarily on non-linguistic visual cues (e.g., the location and size of the
mark as displayed on a product package) rather than the mark's semantic
meaning.
We then present a series of empirical studies of these
assumptions (in Part V). Our empirical investigation seeks to measure word mark
distinctiveness in the relevant context of trademark use. Using a series of
stimuli representative of consumer packaged goods, we hold constant the various
contextual indicators of meaning (such as prominence and placement of the word
mark on the package) while varying the word marks that appear in the context of
the package. This methodology allows us to measure the impact of the
classification of a particular word mark--as generic, descriptive, suggestive,
arbitrary, or fanciful--on trademark distinctiveness. Our study thus allows us
to offer an empirical answer to the trademark distinctiveness question long
determined by judicial intuition and precedent. Our empirical findings
thoroughly undercut the word mark taxonomy that has long dictated the coverage
of the Lanham Act. We demonstrate that descriptive marks are no less source-indicating than suggestive,
arbitrary, and fanciful marks. We also show that it is the non-lexical cues of
typical trademark use (e.g., the location and size of the mark) that cause
consumers to find descriptive marks to be source-indicating.
Finally (in Part VI), we offer some observations
about the implications of our findings for the law's treatment of word marks.
Our principal conclusion is that the law's treatment of “merely descriptive”
marks cannot be justified on the basis of its faulty premises of
distinctiveness. The main implication of that conclusion is a proposal to
jettison legal tests that are based on those premises. Thus, we advocate the
abandonment of the Abercrombie dichotomy between “inherently distinctive” and
“non-inherently distinctive” word marks, eliminating (at the threshold protectability
stage) the longstanding categories of descriptive, suggestive, arbitrary, and
fanciful trademarks. Under our approach, all non-generic word marks would be
eligible for protection so long as they satisfy the “trademark use”
requirement. . . .
The approach we advocate is admittedly heretical, as it calls
for a substantial overhaul of a system of classification that has long stood as
an unquestioned fixture of trademark law. But if that fixture can be shown to
be indefensible on theoretical and empirical grounds, it deserves to be
questioned. Once “merely descriptive” words are seen as distinctive
source-indicators when used in a typical “trademark use” context, they should
not be foreclosed from protection on the basis of erroneous assumptions about
consumer psychology.
Heretical indeed!
What do you think?
Thursday, 17 October 2013
Funds for the super-rich? Sort of ...
At last, the UK Government is taking steps to help the rich -- the IP-rich, that is. Today's media release from the Department for Business Innovation & Skills, and the Intellectual Property Office for which it is responsible, carries the promising title "Plans unveiled to support IP-rich businesses get funding". Sadly, the reality isn't quite as generous. The media release reads as follows:
A new report to government has highlighted the challenges small and medium-sized businesses face when trying to manage and protect their intellectual property.Speaking at the Alliance for Intellectual Property Conference in London today [on which see IPKat reports here and here], Business Secretary Vince Cable welcomed the recommendations from the independent ‘Banking on IP?’ report commissioned by the Intellectual Property Office which examines the issue of access to finance for IP [you can find the executive summary for Banking on IP? here: it's 12 pages long, with a generous allocation of white space].
The executive report published today recommends a series of steps including:
- creating a toolkit to help SMEs, lenders and other financiers identify, understand and make more effective use of their IP
- making it easier for businesses to show what IP they have when looking for funding
- developing templates and providing advice which help banks and others understand the cash flow and business value of IP
- supporting the development of more accessible and effective IP marketplaces
[This blogger's experience suggests that even quite naive SME folk generally have a better idea of their intellectual assets than many supposedly trained and sophisticated finance providers; he wonders if separate tool-kits are needed for SMEs and lenders, since their interests and the consequences of their exposure to risk are quite different] The full report, to be published shortly, recommends ways to help businesses, particularly SMEs, seek investment from banks to protect and invest in their IP. It also recommends ways to give banks the right information and support to value IP correctly ..."
Monday, 14 October 2013
Berlin's Hi-Tech Future: High, Low, or Somewhere in Between?
This blogger had not really devoted much time to considering the start-up environment in Germany, beyond a general awareness that Berlin was a magnet for creative types from all over the globe. That all changed when his son recently informed him that he was taking his newly-minted double degree in computer science and psychology and joining a start-up in Berlin. It was good timing, then, that the October 5 issue of The Economist included an instructive article entitled “A Slow Climb: Business Creation in Germany”, here, with the sub-heading: “A vigorous start-up scene has yet to produce its first big breakthrough.” Both for this blogger and his son, the article discusses a number of key factors that distinguish the hi-tech start-up scene in Berlin from other creative hot-beds, an environment that is falling short, at least for the moment, from the carry-through from seeing a start-up being “founded every 20 hours” to the flotation and exit atmosphere that characterizes a start-up milieu such as Israel.Let’s begin with a sobering fact: Germany does not appear to have spawned a world-beating hi-tech start-up since the founding of SAP in 1972 here. While German ingenuity, encapsulated by the industrial success of its family-owned Mittelstand, is well-recognized, here, this industrial model does not seem to have translated well into the digital world. This is so even as venture capital flows into Germany, in general, and Berlin, in particular (more such investments were reportedly made in Berlin than in London during the last quarter). The article discusses some of the possible reasons for this.
First, Germans appear to have a less enthusiastic view of entrepreneurs than do many of their neighbours. Fewer than 50% of those surveyed in Germany had a positive view about starting a business, compared with 65% in France, 68% in Poland and 79% in the Netherlands. This may be connected to another data point, namely, Germans have a higher level of fear of failure (42%), as compared with 32% in the US.
Secondly, the environment for financing start-ups in Germany has some serious deficiencies. Angel investors and venture capitalists, the life-blood of many start-ups at their formative stage, appear to be less robust than in the US. Thus, it is reported, while the average such investment in Germany is around $1 million dollars, the comparable figure is $6 million dollars (though this blogger is not quite sure what is the basis for these figures). Added to this is the fact that successful entrepreneurs in Germany are far less likely than their US counterparts to then become angel investors themselves.
Thirdly, it appears that German investors are more cautious. Instead of betting on a lot of companies, with the hope that a small number will succeed, German investors tend to invest in a smaller number of companies. In addition, German investors appear to have shorter time horizon for expecting the company to reach a break-even point. In part this can be explained perhaps by the nature of the typical start-up investor, which tends to be a large German company, such as Deutsche Telekom and the publisher, Axel Springer Verlag, here. While such a litany of corporate behemoths is impressive, it is hardly the kind of investment dynamic that one senses in the likes of Sand Hill Road in Menlo Park, California here, where a world-beating number of venture capital companies are seemingly found on every corner.
Pushing against this gloom are a number of factors that, it is argued, point to a much brighter future for German start-ups (and Berlin in particular). These include relatively low costs (from employee salaries to rents), the ever-increasing concentration of creative types, and the cutting-edge reputation of Berlin, especially for “20 (and 30)-somethings”. The German government is also committed to increasing financial support, although the relative pros and cons of government support in hi-tech endeavours continues to be debated.
The article ends with a luke-warm (as compared with the US) assessment of the likely future of the Berlin hi-tech environment, stating as follows:
Perhaps this is too bleak an assessment. After all, how many imagined “swinging Berlin” at the outset of German reunification.“Digital Berlin is now nurturing the sorts of companies that could make pulse-quickening stockmarket debuts, if Germany had a shareholder culture vibrant enough to welcome them. As it is, many are likely to wind up in the hands of incumbents like Telekom and Springer. A few will soar on their own. Germany may not produce the next Google, but perhaps the land of Mercedes and the Mitttlestand does not need to.”
What Digital Berlin will look like a decade hence may also yield unimagined hi-tech surprises. At the least, this blogger will have an inside view of the dynamics taking place there.
Sunday, 13 October 2013
California Governor Jerry Brown Vetoes California’s Biosimilars Bill
I recently wrote
about California’s Biosimilars Bill which was passed by the California
Legislation. California Governor Jerry Brown vetoed the Biosimilars Bill today.
The Sacramento Bee discusses the veto, here.
The Bill arguably made it more difficult for a pharmacist to provide a
biosimilar for a prescribed biologic, thus allowing biologic companies to place
a barrier on the ease of substitution of biosimilars for biologics. The generic pharmaceutical industry as well
as the California Public Employees’ Retirement System (CalPERS) opposed the legislation. The federal Food and Drug Administration also
raised concerns about the Bill. The Bill was supported by the Biotechnology Industry Organization and Amgen. The
Governor issued the following statement concerning the Bill:
To Members of the
California State Senate:
Senate Bill 598 would
effect two changes to our state’s pharmacy law.
First , it would allow interchangeable “biosimilar” drugs to be
substituted for biologic drugs, once these interchangeable drugs are approved
by the federal Food and Drug Administration (FDA). This is a policy I strongly support.
Second, it requires
pharmacists to send notifications back to prescribers about which drug was
dispensed. This requirement, which on
its face looks reasonable, is for some reason highly controversial. Doctors with whom I have spoken would welcome
this information. CalPERS and other
large purchasers warn that the requirement itself would cast doubt on the
safety and desirability of more cost effective alternatives to biologics.
The FDA, which has
jurisdiction for approving all drugs, has not yet determined what standards
will be required for biosimilars to meet the higher threshold of “interchangeability.”
Given this fact, to require physician
notification at this point strikes me as premature.
For these reasons, I
am returning SB 598 without my signature.
Nicely done, Governor. Friday, 11 October 2013
Should You Hire An Auditor To Ensure You Are Obtaining All of Your Royalties? Invotex Thinks You Should Hire It and Here is Why.
Invotex is an accounting, financial and economic consulting
firm that provides expert services in litigation, forensic and valuation
support; intellectual property services; insurance services; and restructuring
and investigation services. As part of
its suite of intellectual property services, Invotex offers royalty audits and
compliance services. And, as Professor
Crouch at the excellent Patently O Blog recently noted, Invotex has released
its 13th Annual Invotex Royalty Compliance Report. The report's headline states, in part, “89% of Audited
Licensees Underreport and Underpay Royalties.”
According to Invotex, there has been a trend up in underreporting and
underpaying royalties since it started creating reports in 2007. The audits included in the report appear to
be of companies that Invotex was hired to audit. It is unclear, however, how many companies
were audited by Invotex for this report; although the press release notes that “hundreds
of agreements” have been audited by Invotex and Invotex has recovered “$150
million in underpaid royalties.” Invotex
states that:
Best practice dictates a systematic license compliance program that includes royalty audits. Audits typically generate positive results for the licensor and can turn your “cost center” into a revenue-generating resource.
Underreported
Royalties as a Percent of Reported Royalties
In our examinations, we found that in a high percentage of cases, licensees owed the licensor more than two times the amount paid in royalties. As a percentage of reported royalties, we found that of all licensees:
In our examinations, we found that in a high percentage of cases, licensees owed the licensor more than two times the amount paid in royalties. As a percentage of reported royalties, we found that of all licensees:
·
25%
underreport the royalties they owe by more than 100% of the total amount
reported
·
7%
underreport the royalties they owe by 50 to 99% of the total amount reported
·
8%
underreport the royalties they owe by 25 to 49%
·
11%
underreport the royalties they owe by 11 - 24%
·
11%
underreport the royalties they owe by 6 to 10%
·
27%
underreport royalties they owe by 1 to 5%
·
11%
accurately report royalties owed
Invotex also
helpfully reports the reasons for underreporting. Notably, the report states that, “56% underreport sales; [and] questionable
license interpretation accounts for 44% of the total misreported dollar amount.” Apparently, Invotex has, perhaps unsurprisingly,
found that licensees will interpret certain terms such as “the definition of
the product to how to calculate the sale” in ways that result in lower royalty
amounts. This interpretation issue can
be the result of poor drafting and Invotex notes that, “outright fraud is a
rare occurrence.” The report states other sources of underreported
royalty amounts including: Royalties from Disallowed Deductions; Math Errors;
Royalty Rate Errors; Unreported Sublicenses; Transfer Prices; and Unreported
Benchmarks and Milestones. Invotex also
reports that it audited a major pharmaceutical company on behalf of a research
university and found that, “Based on our audit, an underpayment of more than
75% of what had originally been reported to the client was uncovered and paid
to our client. This underpayment was based on the overestimation of discounts,
the use of transfer prices instead of third party pricing and the
misclassification of sublicensee revenue.”
In a recent article
in Corporate Counsel, Invotex’s Deborah R. Stewart and Judy A. Byrd offer
advice for how to maximize the opportunity to receive 100% of the royalties you
are entitled. Ms. Stewart and Ms.
Byrd provide a sage “Takeaway”:
The role of
in-house counsel is changing. Many corporate counsel are now evaluated not only
on effectiveness and efficiency, but increasingly, on how they contribute to
the company’s financial bottom line. Capturing the full value of your corporate
royalties will increase your firm’s revenue. The solution may be easier than
you realize.
Best practice dictates a systematic license compliance program that includes royalty audits. Audits typically generate positive results for the licensor and can turn your “cost center” into a revenue-generating resource.
IP licensing is
one of the most significant and fastest-growing sources of an organization’s
earnings, yet it remains one of the most poorly managed and underutilized
assets. Managing a successful licensee compliance program is like managing
everything else. It takes time and interest to keep it on track.
Are the experiences of readers of this blog similar in discovering
underreporting of royalties?
Labels:
audits,
invotex,
licensing revenue,
royalties,
royalty audits,
royalty reporting,
royalty reports
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








